Opinion

Letter: Where the Poor in San Diego Live

 

Even though poverty has hit a historic high rate in San Diego, the region is not perceived to have poverty areas. Latest census data shows significant concentration of poverty in certain neighborhoods.

There were 361,000 San Diegans living below the federal poverty level, with an additional 253,000 that were “near poor” with incomes 50 percent above the poverty line, during the period 2006-2010. People living in or near poverty tend to be concentrated in certain neighborhoods rather than being evenly distributed through the region. This concentration of poverty can lead to aggravation of environmental factors within the neighborhood, such as higher crime, lower public investments, struggling schools, etc. that impact the income mobility of residents to move out of poverty.

One drawback of using the federal poverty rate in classifying San Diego census tracts is that the federal rate does not account for the high cost of living in San Diego. Poverty status is determined by comparing annual income to a set of dollar values called poverty thresholds that vary by family size, number of children, and age of householder (e.g. poverty threshold for a family of four with two children was $22,113 in 2010). These poverty thresholds are updated annually to allow for changes in the cost of living over time, but they do not vary geographically. Therefore, the federal poverty threshold is likely to undercount poverty in San Diego, and thus dilute the measures of poverty concentration.

The American Community Survey is generating 5-year estimates annually, which allows us to track how poverty changes over time within the region. Using a baseline of 13.8 percent, which was the poverty rate for the U.S. during the period 2006-2010 when the data was collected, a recent publication of the U.S Census Bureau has generated four categories of census tracts.

Category I includes census tracts with poverty rates less than 13.8 percent. Category II includes those with poverty rates of 13.8 percent to 19.9 percent. Category III includes those with poverty rates of 20.0 percent to 39.9 percent, and Category IV includes those tracts with poverty rates of 40.0 percent or more. Census tracts with poverty rates equal or greater than 20.0 percent (Categories III and IV) are referred to as “poverty areas.”

The areas with the highest concentration of poverty (Category IV) in San Diego include 13 census tracts that are primarily concentrated in Mid-City and around downtown Centre City (including Barrio Logan, Logan Heights). Although little has changed over the past decade in areas of extreme concentration, other pockets of poverty are emerging throughout the region. Other poverty areas (Category III) include 121 census tracts that are scattered throughout the region including in the city of San Diego (Mid-City, Centre City, Southeastern San Diego, University City, Kearny Mesa), as well as South Bay (National City, Chula Vista), and East County (El Cajon and Escondido). The map below shows the concentration of poverty in the region.

One-in-five San Diegans lives in a poverty area. The combined aggregated household income of these areas is 12 percent of the total income in the region, and they accommodate 47 percent of those below poverty. These areas also have slightly fewer full-time year-round workers, and more female heads of households. These characteristics are quite similar to the national data, where the concentration of poverty in poverty areas is slightly more than in San Diego.

One-in-three Latino San Diegans lives in a poverty area. Those with Hispanic/Latino origin and Blacks/African Americans were over-represented in tracts with higher poverty rates and under-represented in tracts with lower poverty rates. In contrast, non-Hispanic Whites and Asians were more likely to live in tracts with lower poverty rates than in tracts with higher poverty rates.

Where you live in San Diego is indicative of how much economic hardship you are likely to witness from your neighbors. In San Diego, the basic needs budget for self-sufficiency often exceeds 200 percent of the federal poverty level. Whereas those who reside in Category I tracts see about one-in-five neighbors below this threshold; within Category III and IV tracts, more than half of all your neighbors are likely to be struggling to make ends meet.

This picture of poverty in San Diego has emerged through boom and bust times. It is a five-year portrait of the geography of poverty in the region, with the difficult stroke of economic hardship brushing over the fabric of our neighborhoods.

Murtaza Baxamusa is the Director of Planning and Development for the San Diego Building Trades Family Housing Corporation. He lives in Bird Rock.


Want to contribute to discussion? Submit a suggestion to Fix San Diego.

Voice of San Diego is a nonprofit that depends on you, our readers. Please donate to keep the service strong. Click here to find out more about our supporters and how we operate independently.


Murtaza Baxamusa

Murtaza Baxamusa

Murtaza Baxamusa works for the San Diego Building Trades Family Housing Corp. and volunteered as a special policy adviser for Bob Filner.

  • 29 Posts
  • 2
    Followers

Show comments
Before you comment, read these simple guidelines on what is not allowed.

16 comments
Jim Jones
Jim Jones subscriber

Murtaza, the Auditor General of California has put out some reports on numbers of illegals here. That would be a good place to start on getting a handle on the root causes and cures of this poverty issue, what causes the high numbers and what we need to do to fix it.

Jim Jones
Jim Jones

Murtaza, the Auditor General of California has put out some reports on numbers of illegals here. That would be a good place to start on getting a handle on the root causes and cures of this poverty issue, what causes the high numbers and what we need to do to fix it.

Murtaza Baxamusa
Murtaza Baxamusa subscribermember

Census does not ask questions about legal status of immigrants.

Murtaza
Murtaza

Census does not ask questions about legal status of immigrants.

Vincent Stevens
Vincent Stevens subscriber

Jim never misses an opportunity to put his boot on the neck of immigrants, or anyone else that disagrees with him

SDvet
SDvet

Jim never misses an opportunity to put his boot on the neck of immigrants, or anyone else that disagrees with him

Vincent Stevens
Vincent Stevens subscriber

I think most of us living south of interstate 8 already knew this.

SDvet
SDvet

I think most of us living south of interstate 8 already knew this.

Kelly Donivan
Kelly Donivan subscriber

It would have been helpful to see these charts more clearly. My eyesight isn't that good. Also...Jim Jones has a point. How many of these folks in poverty are illegal aliens? I would have to guess that they contribute to much of this poverty.

Genxer65
Genxer65

It would have been helpful to see these charts more clearly. My eyesight isn't that good. Also...Jim Jones has a point. How many of these folks in poverty are illegal aliens? I would have to guess that they contribute to much of this poverty.

Jim Jones
Jim Jones subscriber

Strip the illegals out of the equation and see where we stand.

Jim Jones
Jim Jones

Strip the illegals out of the equation and see where we stand.

bobb haole
bobb haole subscriber

this really needs to be edited.

haolebobb
haolebobb

this really needs to be edited.

Doug Porter
Doug Porter subscriber

Now we know exactly where Carl Demaio won't campaign.

dougbob
dougbob

Now we know exactly where Carl Demaio won't campaign.