Filner’s Pension Plan Is a Non-Existent Panacea

Filner’s Pension Plan Is a Non-Existent Panacea

Photo by Sam Hodgson

Bob Filner

 

San Diego mayoral candidate Bob Filner’s pension plan is his panacea.

It allows him to claim he’ll fix the city’s longest standing financial crisis, its debt-ridden pension system. It puts $550 million into the city’s day-to-day operating budget over the next 10 years, he says, money that can fix potholes and improve public safety. Its success even will allow him to establish credibility in city government, enough to eventually ask San Diegans to approve new taxes.

There’s just one problem. Filner’s plan doesn’t exist yet.

Two hundred and eighty days ago, Filner, a Democratic congressman, announced he was running for mayor. At his announcement, he said he would release his pension plan in “about a month.” He didn’t. And during the next nine months he’s said repeatedly his plan is only days or weeks away. But instead of his actual proposal, he’s only given excuses for why it’s not ready yet.

To be sure, Filner has given outlines of his plan. He wants to cap pensions for new hires at $106,000, enter into a five-year agreement with labor groups and refinance the pension debt to pay it off over a longer term. The last part is the centerpiece and Filner is expected to credit it for the most savings at the expense of delaying pension payments. He’s presenting the plan as an alternative to a Republican and business-backed initiative that gives most new city employees 401(k)s instead of pensions.

In a mayoral forum Wednesday in Mission Valley, Filner used his pension ideas as a cudgel against his three Republican opponents, who all support the existing initiative. Filner says his ideas will save more money.

But without seeing his plan on paper, the public has no way of knowing if he’s telling the truth.

By this point, Filner’s twists, turns and false starts on releasing his plan have become comedic. But they also reveal a key point about his candidacy. Unlike his three main opponents, Filner hasn’t released any specific policy platforms about anything — not just pensions. This isn’t entirely by design. At one point, Filner wanted his alternative pension plan to go on the June ballot, too. The deadline for that to happen has just passed.

We thought the best way to look at Filner’s pension plan foibles was to present them, and some related events, in a timeline. Here’s the long and winding road starting with Filner’s mayoral announcement and ending with still nothing on paper.

June 8, 2011. Filner announces for mayor. An alternative pension plan, he says, is on its way. “About a month.”

Aug. 19, 2011. Filner outlines his pension plan. He wants to cap pensions for new employees at $125,000 a year, force employees to take unspecified concessions and lessen the city’s annual pension payments through refinancing its debt. He also says he wants his plan on the June ballot to compete with the Republican-backed initiative. “You can’t fight something with nothing.”

Aug. 25, 2011. District Attorney Bonnie Dumanis, another mayoral candidate, flips her position and now supports the pension initiative, leaving Filner the only major candidate to oppose it.

Sept. 7, 2011. City Council President Tony Young says he’s open to an alternative pension ballot measure, but hasn’t seen one from Filner or anyone else.

Sept. 16, 2011. Filner tells our own Scott Lewis on the radio that his pension plan will be available soon. “It’s being run through accountants and actuaries and we hope to have an answer soon.”

Sept. 30, 2011. Backers of the existing pension initiative turn in 145,027 signatures to the City Clerk, 50,000 more than they need for it to qualify for the June ballot.

Nov. 8, 2011. Elections officials verify the pension initiative’s signatures, ensuring it will appear on the ballot.

Dec. 12, 2011. The city’s white-collar union endorses Filner. After a press conference, Filner says he’s given a draft of his pension proposal in writing to city council members. “Most of them have it.” Public records requests to city council members turn up nothing.

Dec. 16, 2011. U-T San Diego editorialist Bill Osborne tweets it has been 190 days since Filner said he would “soon” release his pension plan.

Jan. 8, 2012. Filner tells the U-T he’s still crunching numbers on his plan.

Jan. 13, 2012. At the first mayoral debate with all four major candidates, Filner is asked a direct question about his pension plan. He says the pension cap now is $106,000 (not $125,000). He also fleshed out some more specifics. He’ll have a five-year labor agreement. He’ll refinance the pension debt. He claims the plan will save $500 million over the next decade. “The only way we can get out of this pension mess is not by throwing the public employees under the bus.”

Feb. 7, 2012. Democratic City Councilman David Alvarez releases his own alternative to the pension initiative that caps pensions at $99,999 for new hires.

Feb. 9, 2012. Young squashes Alvarez’s plan, saying there isn’t enough time before the March 9 ballot deadline to have a real debate.

Feb. 10, 2012. Filner tells the U-T he plans to release his plan sometime in the next week, but wanted to see a financial analysis of the existing initiative first. “I have mine ready, I just want to make sure all my charts and graphs are ready to show more savings than (fellow candidate Carl) DeMaio’s.”

Feb. 11, 2012. One of Filner’s highest-profile endorsers, former City Councilwoman Donna Frye, tells our Andrew Donohue that she disagrees with Filner’s proposal to refinance pension debt and has told him so.

Feb. 13, 2012. A state labor board asks for temporary restraining order to block the pension initiative from reaching the ballot. In response, Filner tells NBC 7 San Diego he might release his plan at the next day’s City Council meeting or might delay it depending on the result of the labor complaint.

Feb. 21, 2012. A judge denies the labor board’s request to block the existing initiative from appearing on the ballot.

Feb. 27, 2012. The U-T’s City Hall reporter, Craig Gustafson, tweets that Filner told him the pension plan is on paper and Gustafson could have it any time. He says Filner said that two weeks prior.

March 9, 2012. Filner misses the deadline for the City Council to put measures on the June ballot. That means his plan can’t compete with the Republican-backed initiative like he had wanted.

March 14, 2012. Filner talks extensively about his pension plan at a mayoral forum in Mission Valley. Afterward, he says it’s still on its way. The circumstances keep changing, he says, and it’s only responsible for him to have the most updated information. “We’ve got two-and-a-half months before the election,” he says.

Liam Dillon is a news reporter for voiceofsandiego.org. He covers San Diego City Hall, the 2012 mayor’s race and big building projects. What should he write about next?

Please contact him directly at liam.dillon@voiceofsandiego.org or 619.550.5663.

Like VOSD on Facebook.

Voice of San Diego is a nonprofit that depends on you, our readers. Please donate to keep the service strong. Click here to find out more about our supporters and how we operate independently.


Liam Dillon

Liam Dillon

Liam Dillon is senior reporter and assistant editor for Voice of San Diego. He leads VOSD’s investigations and writes about how regular people interact with local government. What should he write about next? Please contact him directly at liam.dillon@voiceofsandiego.org or 619.550.5663.

  • 916 Posts
  • 6
    Followers

Show comments
Before you comment, read these simple guidelines on what is not allowed.

20 comments
John de Beck
John de Beck subscriber

While DeMaio babbles on with OVERSTATEMENTS about HIS PLAN (Which won't work) Filner calmly regards the situation and considers options. In selling ideas, the best plan is to UNDERSTATE what you or your product will do and OVERPROVE by performance. US military veterans and others who have seen Filner perform understand he will get things done WITHOUT overstating his goals. Clearly a measure of rational thinking. DeMaio's confrontational style may work for minds locked in cement, but Filner's pragmatism makes him a far better candidate for mayor.

deBeck
deBeck

While DeMaio babbles on with OVERSTATEMENTS about HIS PLAN (Which won't work) Filner calmly regards the situation and considers options. In selling ideas, the best plan is to UNDERSTATE what you or your product will do and OVERPROVE by performance. US military veterans and others who have seen Filner perform understand he will get things done WITHOUT overstating his goals. Clearly a measure of rational thinking. DeMaio's confrontational style may work for minds locked in cement, but Filner's pragmatism makes him a far better candidate for mayor.

Jim Jones
Jim Jones subscriber

In politics the back seat is no place to steer from. Of course Filners probably seen the numbers and sees winning the office is a long shot. Maybe like Dumanis he is just in it to have run and doesn't want to win?

Jim Jones
Jim Jones

In politics the back seat is no place to steer from. Of course Filners probably seen the numbers and sees winning the office is a long shot. Maybe like Dumanis he is just in it to have run and doesn't want to win?

Mark Giffin
Mark Giffin subscribermember

That is either very smart or very stupid. Time will tell.

mgland
mgland

That is either very smart or very stupid. Time will tell.

Frank O'Grady
Frank O'Grady subscriber

Nor could the people who consume the pablum they produce.

soulpatch
soulpatch

Nor could the people who consume the pablum they produce.

Bill Bradshaw
Bill Bradshaw subscribermember

Second. We know at least one detail about his plan. He wants to cap pensions, but only for the highest paid (i.e., management). That will ensure we get and keep the best and brightest, maybe people even smarter than the ones managing the city today. I can hardly wait!

toulon
toulon

Second. We know at least one detail about his plan. He wants to cap pensions, but only for the highest paid (i.e., management). That will ensure we get and keep the best and brightest, maybe people even smarter than the ones managing the city today. I can hardly wait!

Jim Jones
Jim Jones subscriber

Anything that comes out of his mouth is just politician speak for "Club the baby taxpayer and give the fur to the public unions"

Jim Jones
Jim Jones

Anything that comes out of his mouth is just politician speak for "Club the baby taxpayer and give the fur to the public unions"

Tammy Tran
Tammy Tran subscriber

Congressman Filner's plan to keep pensions for future City employees is good for your children, your grandchildren, your relatives if they happen to be a City employee someday.

TammyT
TammyT

Congressman Filner's plan to keep pensions for future City employees is good for your children, your grandchildren, your relatives if they happen to be a City employee someday.

Richard Rider
Richard Rider subscribermember

Filner will submit his pension reform plan as soon as the union bosses tell him what the plan is. Not a moment before.

Richard Rider
Richard Rider

Filner will submit his pension reform plan as soon as the union bosses tell him what the plan is. Not a moment before.

Lyle Beller
Lyle Beller subscribermember

If we "refinance the pension debt to pay it off over a longer term", wouldn't that increase the total interest payments over the life of the loan ? That seems like a move calculated to reduce payments during one mayor's term while leaving some future mayor holding the bag. Perhaps Mr. Filner doesn't want to release his plan too soon because that would allow us the time to read and understand it before the election.

frugal
frugal

If we "refinance the pension debt to pay it off over a longer term", wouldn't that increase the total interest payments over the life of the loan ? That seems like a move calculated to reduce payments during one mayor's term while leaving some future mayor holding the bag. Perhaps Mr. Filner doesn't want to release his plan too soon because that would allow us the time to read and understand it before the election.

Mark Giffin
Mark Giffin subscribermember

If you believe the "mission" of government is public employee wages and benefits then he is your man

mgland
mgland

If you believe the "mission" of government is public employee wages and benefits then he is your man