Trying to be everything to everyone is a pretty common approach to politics.

Just look how far it’s gotten Mayor Kevin Faulconer.

But often when you make pleasing everyone your goal, you end up just saying nothing at all – and pleasing no one.

That was certainly the case with a statement released this week by Councilwoman Barbara Bry in response to the mass shooting in her district. You can see Bry trying to bend backward in both directions – hoping not to offend the victims, who are upset over the police quickly dismissing race as a motive in the shooting, and the police department, an agency with which Bry works on the Council.

The fact that almost all of the victims are people of color cannot be ignored. The survivors of this attack have spoken out and believe that people of color were targeted by the shooter.

The SDPD is conducting a thorough investigation, and I applaud their diligence in handling this case. I am hopeful that the investigation will shed light on the motives behind this devastating attack.

Reading that is kind of like eating a cotton ball. You know your eyes just processed words, and yet they carry no meaning. The victims’ belief they were targeted must not be ignored. But also … the police are working thoroughly and diligently. Faulconer, the master of saying nothing and offending no one, would be proud.

Contrast that with a statement released by Councilman David Alvarez this week dealing with the mayor’s proposed budget and the San Diego Police Department’s officer retention problem. He takes direct aim at Chief Shelley Zimmerman’s insistence that the problem is out of her control – it’s the national media’s fault! – and says the city needs to use data to get to work crafting a solution.

I am worried that we have begun treating this problem as something natural, as something that we are powerless to solve. From my perspective, that approach is a dereliction of duty. The leadership of the City and SDPD must confront this problem head on, crunch the data to find out how we can solve it, and then solve it. We need solutions, not excuses. At minimum, we owe it to our police officers and our residents to develop a plan of action to increase police retention and recruitment.

Bry and Alvarez were of course speaking about different things. The shooting that was the impetus for Bry’s statement is a much more tragic and sensitive issue than what is ultimately a budget dispute. Still, whether you agree with the substance of Alvarez’s statement or not, this town sure could use more statements that carry real meaning and politicians who are willing to take on powerful entities.

What VOSD Learned This Week

I talked with DA hopeful Summer Stephan about a host of criminal justice issues, including rape kits, that explosive guilt-by-association gang prosecution and police body cameras. She signaled a willingness to do things differently than District Attorney Bonnie Dumanis but never outright said any of Dumanis’ decisions were wrong.

Scott Lewis and Andy Keatts grilled Stephan about the peculiar politics of it all. Many critics have emerged this week saying the interim DA should pledge not to run in 2018. Stephan said those concerns are a red herring.


The peso has been on the decline since 2014 but recently its plunges can be traced to President Donald Trump’s rhetoric and proposals. Business leaders in San Diego worry the region’s manufacturing and tourism industries may feel the impact.

It’s not just San Diego’s economy that’s tethered to Mexico. Leaders in Sacramento this week got an earful about how the state could be harmed if Trump blows up NAFTA.


When San Diego Unified created a whole webpage just to push back against Mario Koran’s stellar graduation rate reporting, it included a pretty rich claim: That Mario’s reporting on students leaving for charter schools didn’t have enough data. The district neglected to mention that was because they literally refused to provide us with data.

Until now. New numbers provided under several public records request offer the clearest view yet of how many students are leaving the district for charter schools. Many of them are leaving from some of the district’s poorest schools.


The state’s major power monopolies, including SDG&E, have a new plan that, if OK’d, would let them keep charging people for power for decades even if those people leave for government-run utilities, called CCAs.

No other political decision on the city’s horizon would more dramatically alter public affairs than whether the city should start a CCA.


The new homeless census numbers showed homelessness in Chula Vista was down, even though it was up around the county. Great news, right? Not necessarily. Lisa Halverstadt notes that the drop was likely because of a new measure banning large vehicles from parking on the street. Advocates think the homeless are simply being pushed elsewhere.

What I’m Reading

• A company with incredibly dangerous working conditions routinely hired immigrants. Then, when those workers got injured or try to secure workplace protections, the company used U.S. immigration laws against them. (ProPublica)

• A sports reporter surveys the scene as her industry crumbles around her. (Medium)

• A wild tale of an FBI translator who went way off script and married an ISIS pitchman. (CNN)

• This story and its haunting images will linger in your head. Venezuela is starving. (Wall Street Journal)

• A lot of media coverage is focused on President Donald Trump’s failures. But he’s quietly succeeded in one big way: terrorizing immigrant communities. (Vox)

• This is a fascinating and well-written column by Amanda Knox on the role of loyalty in politics. (Los Angeles Times)

Line of the Week

“What are they doing? They can go inside and yet they do not. It’s very insane.” – From a hilarious indictment of people who love camping.

Sara Libby was VOSD’s managing editor until 2021. She oversaw VOSD’s newsroom and content.

Leave a comment

We expect all commenters to be constructive and civil. We reserve the right to delete comments without explanation. You are welcome to flag comments to us. You are welcome to submit an opinion piece for our editors to review.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.