Image via Shutterstock

In response to the Trump administration’s crackdown on undocumented immigrants, San Diego immigration advocates came together in December to officially launch a rapid response network.

Networks like this have been popping up around the country, not only in response to the recent surge in immigration enforcement, but during the last decade.


Eight years ago, Alianza Comunitaria started a network in North County that alerts people of raids and checkpoints. During the Lilac Fire, it provided information about shelters and other updates.

After the launch of the San Diego rapid response network, I wanted to learn more about how these networks actually work, how they help immigrant communities facing enforcement crackdowns and what it takes to organize and operate them.

I started by calling Marisela Esperanza, the program manager of San Francisco Immigrant Legal & Education Network, who currently coordinates the San Francisco Rapid Response Network — the oldest of its kind in the country. That same morning the San Francisco Chronicle had published a story describing a massive immigration sweep in Northern California, so she was in the middle of mobilizing the rapid response network in preparation.

Esperanza said the San Francisco network took hold in 2008 after a series of raids there in which ICE agents entered nearly a dozen restaurants, arresting more than 60 undocumented immigrants.

“Immigration (enforcement) doesn’t always follow due process, and we needed to ensure that the individuals knew what their rights were,” she said.

Back then, the network was pretty rudimentary, Esperanza said. People would carry and share prepaid cellphones, and staff and volunteers would help activate the network if word of any immigration enforcement came. Last year, the network revamped with a 24-hour hotline in multiple languages. If someone calls a network, staff and volunteers will first verify whether the enforcement involves ICE, Esperanza said. Often people will call mistaking local police or private security for immigration officials.

Once the immigration enforcement activity is verified, the network will send out trained volunteers to do legal observation. They don’t engage with the officers and the individual who is being questioned or apprehended, but simply record the interaction. Trained staff will also go to the scene to collect information from families or detainees.

The network then has a team of attorneys who are ready to be dispatched and counsel those impacted. The attorneys will attempt to get detainees released or ensure they aren’t transferred out of state or deported immediately.

The last arm of the network is something referred to as “accompaniment.” These are volunteers who will provide transportation to an immigration appointment, show up to court to prove the individual in question isn’t a flight risk, provide a place to sleep if someone is scared to go home after immigration officials come to their home, or even provide food or raise money for a family whose breadwinner has been detained.

“It takes a lot of resources,” Esperanza said. “Resources in the form of people. It takes resources in the form of cash. It can be taxing. A lot of the time people are playing multiple rolls, putting out fires. For us, we have been supported by the city of San Francisco… so we have coordinated, paid dispatchers, paid attorneys, where it is their job to respond to these instances.”

In San Diego, the network is newer and smaller, funded and run by local advocacy, civil rights and labor organizations without local government support.

“There was too much at risk and too much at stake to not give up resources and staff time to dedicate to this,” said Dinora Reyna, one of San Diego Organizing Project’s community organizers.

Similar to San Francisco, volunteers run a 24-hour hotline. The network uses software and technology from the national faith-based organizing network PICO to alert and verify immigration arrests. In San Diego, these arrests will activate a legal team led and coordinated by Jewish Family Service that will match either one of their attorneys or one from another nonprofit to each case.

Reyna said the network has fielded almost 400 calls in the past month. Most people are verifying the number or trying to get a referral for services, but they’ve had a handful of real cases where people have been detained or picked up.

“We are hearing the threats from the White House,” Reyna said. “We’re hearing clearly the stance of the current administration. We’re getting ready. That’s the value of the network. We’re not allowing for anyone to go through a deportation or arrest alone. Because we are so close to the border, we’re building this and we’re committed that if we can’t stop the deportation machine, we can make sure families don’t do this by themselves.”

Baja California Grapples With Pot

Last week, Mexico’s tourism chief proposed legalizing marijuana in Mexican states where Americans frequent, including Los Cabos in Baja California Sur. Baja California and Quintana Roo — home to Cancun — have been hard hit by surges in violence in the country in the past year.

The Minister for Tourism, Enrique de la Madrid, said the move could help reduce that violence.

It comes after the country legalized marijuana for medical and scientific purposes last June. The actual regulations haven’t been finalized and put into place yet.

Between the loosening of medical use at home and full-blown legalization across the northern border, Baja California is in a particularly interesting position. Earlier this month, the country’s Secretary of Public Security expressed concern that marijuana from California was being smuggled into the state, something that KPBS’ Jean Guerrero reported back in 2016 was already happening as some tijuanenses sought more potent strains.

To throw another variable into the patchwork of pot regulations in the region, the border itself is still U.S. federal territory, where even medical marijuana is illegal. If marijuana in some form ends up legalized on both sides of the border, it may not be able to pass freely between countries.

A History Untold is Finally Told

The Chula Vista Heritage Museum / Photo by Adriana Heldiz

On Saturday, a year-long museum exhibit on the history of Spanish-speaking people in South Bay opened in the Chula Vista Civic Center public library branch, based on research done by local journalist and historian Barbara Zaragoza.

Zaragoza said after she wrote about San Ysidro and the Tijuana River Valley, a friend asked where all the Latinos were in her first book.

“It was a white history,” Zaragoza said. “This history had never been told. We had a history in downtown San Diego and Barrio Logan. We had a history in Tijuana. We had a history of Lemon Grove, but we didn’t have a history of the Spanish speaking here, when more than half the people are of Spanish-speaking descent.”

The result was the exhibit and her new book, “Fronterizos: A History of the Spanish-speaking People of the South Bay, San Diego.”

“A lot of the communities here were underserved,” Zaragoza said. “We don’t tell people’s histories when they are underserved.”

A few fun facts I learned from the exhibit: There are families in South Bay who date back to the Portolá expedition, the first recorded Spanish exploration of present-day California, and San Ysidro used to be called Tia Juana City. What today we call Tijuana, San Ysidro and the Tijuana River Valley was once the same massive property, Rancho Tia Juana.

Click here to watch a short video of the event.

More Loopholes in State Law to Protect Immigrants

California may have some of the most protections and ambitious plans to protect unauthorized immigrants in the country. But despite numerous state laws to govern the interaction between local law enforcement, federal officials and undocumented immigrants residing in the state, there seem to be countless loopholes and gray areas that make trying to separate authority impossible.

We’ve found two such examples recently.

First, we discovered that the Escondido Police Department signed a “Certification of Illegal Immigration Cooperation” agreement back in September to obtain a Department of Justice grant. The department hasn’t decided to accept the grant yet, but even if it does, it seems like partaking in such an agreement with the federal government may not be technically out of line with state laws.

Then we revisited a controversial stop made last summer by sheriff’s deputies in Mission Bay, where Border Patrol somehow ended up on the scene to apprehend two individuals for immigration-related reasons.

The Justice Department threatened to subpoena 23 “sanctuary” jurisdictions, including the entire state of California. (Politico)

More Border News:

A U.S. beer manufacturing production plant proposed in Mexicali could inject more than $1 billion into the region but faces pushback over water issues and government corruption. (Union-Tribune)

In 2013, the leader of Mexico’s powerful teachers union was arrested for embezzling millions of dollars for personal expenses, including two homes in Coronado. An investigation finds that a Coronado mansion remains hers to this day. (Sin Embargo)

San Diego and Imperial counties are the only places in the U.S. where health insurance provides some workers access to medical care in Tijuana. (Union-Tribune)

Military tactical assault teams have been trying to melt, saw, torch and scale the border wall prototypes. (Associated Press)

Patrol agents in San Diego are most often assaulted through “rockings.” (Union-Tribune)

California’s attorney general warns employers that they will face fines if they assist immigration officials. (Sacramento Bee)

Tijuana’s condo-building boom is still going strong. (Union-Tribune)

Maya Srikrishnan

Maya was Voice of San Diego’s Associate Editor of Civic Education. She reported on marginalized communities in San Diego and oversees Voice’s explanatory...

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.