FILE - Immigration and Customs Enforcement officers detain a man during an operation on March 15, 2023, in Oceanside. (AP Photo/Gregory Bull, File)

A recent survey found that many Oceanside students are struggling to complete school assignments, focus in class and maintain their grades because of their fears over Immigration and Customs Enforcement activity.

The online survey, conducted by the Human Rights Council of Oceanside, a grassroots, volunteer-based group that monitors human and civil rights in Oceanside, polled middle school and high school students in the area. Almost all of the 58 children who responded to the survey said they worry about ICE while they’re at school — only five children said they rarely or never worry. 

“A lot of us grew up in Oceanside, and we have already gone through this,” said Juanito Xōchipilli Conoro, co-chair of the council. “This is like the second round for us. A lot of the findings in the surveys, a lot of us who have gone through this expected it.”

Conoro said that when they were growing up, their friends would often talk about being afraid of coming home from school to missing parents.

“It’s kind of sad but also predictable that that’s what we’re hearing too today,” Conoro said.

In a part of the survey that allowed students to share anything they wanted to say, many said they are feeling anxious and afraid.

“It is scary going to school everyday knowing that something can happen to my family any second of the day,” an 11th grade student wrote. “We constantly live with the fear of being separated, which does make it difficult to get to and from school.”

Several students expressed concern for friends whose families have been impacted or could be impacted by ICE activity.

“I don’t want my classmates to feel unsafe, and knowing they feel unsafe, makes me feel unsafe, knowing that we can leave campus and something can happen to someone I know honestly hurts me because I don’t want them to live in fear,” a 12th grade student wrote.

Several students who attend El Camino High School complained that some students who don’t come from immigrant families have made ignorant comments or even bullied them over the issue.

Several asked for help with transportation or mental health needs.

The survey results include 24 students — more than 40 percent of those who responded — who said concerns about ICE had affected their ability to get to school. 

Conoro said that statistic hit them especially hard because they realized that they held a lot of stress when passing through any kind of checkpoint because of their own childhood fears. That carried over to their time in the military.

“I remember going onto post, and I remember having this physical reaction all the time going on there,” Conoro said. “I remember thinking why does this keep coming up for me. It took me a while to realize this represented a trauma for me when I was growing up here in Oceanside.”

The council held a meeting Thursday to go over the survey results with parents and students. Conoro said the meeting helped open communication between parents and students. They said many families had struggled to have conversations about the fear.

“This might not be a conversation topic in the household not because they don’t want to but maybe because they don’t know how to handle that conversation,” Conoro said. “One of the things that came up for some of us is ‘What is it that the district can do to bridge that?’”

The council also invited officials from the school district to attend. Two board members — Raquel Alvarez and Nancy Licona — attended along with at least one member of the district’s ICE response team.

Conoro said they were disappointed not to see the superintendent come to the meeting. They said the council has been trying to meet with Superintendent Julie Vitale since March to discuss concerns that parents and students have.

When asked about the superintendent’s absence, district spokesperson Donald Bendz said that Vitale wasn’t invited. Bendz said that Vitale met with the council in the past.

“When meetings are intended to be collaborative then we are happy to meet with community partners,” Bendz said. “This has not been our experience with HRCO.”

Conoro said that the council wants to have a healthy conversation with the superintendent.

“We’re going to be direct, but just because we’re direct doesn’t mean we’re trying to attack you,” Conoro said. “It doesn’t mean we don’t want to work with you. Showing up means there are a lot of other feelings that show up as well. We have the range and capacity to express that and move on.”

At the meeting, according to Conoro, parents identified several needs that aligned with what students said in the survey including transportation, family plans and mental health support.

Jordy Sparks, executive director of DEI and student support for the district, said the district is already providing resources in each of those areas. 

“A lot of this work is not new to us,” Sparks said. “It’s been something that we’ve been building for quite a while now. We have a pretty comprehensive approach.”

He said the district put out a call for volunteers from local churches and farms to transport students who need help because of ICE fears or an arrest in the family, and some students are getting rides through the program.

The district has information about making family emergency plans on its website in English and Spanish. And, Sparks said, it has a counselor at every school, along with social workers and psychologists, to support students’ mental health. It also has a contact person for any concerns related to ICE at each school, he said.

Sparks said the district responds quickly anytime it finds out that ICE has made an arrest in one of its families. He said the district has helped 20 families in that situation, including by sending mental health providers and offering help with groceries.

But, based on the survey results, it doesn’t appear that every family in the district knows about the available programs. Sparks said the district sends out weekly emails that include immigration-related resources and that his team conducts Know Your Rights workshops both at schools and in the community.

“I think the information is out there,” Sparks said. “If there are ways that we can make it more accessible, we’re open to that sort of suggestion.”

Conoro said that parents at the recent council-hosted meeting struggled to navigate the district’s resources and asked for those resources on Facebook or in Whatsapp instead since they use those platforms more frequently.

One man at the meeting said he wished he had known about the family plan process before he was detained, Conoro said.

When asked about the possibility of WhatsApp, Sparks said the district uses other messaging platforms but not WhatsApp for official communications.

“Community members have said, ‘You may be doing all of this, but we don’t know that you’re doing it,’” Conoro said. “OK, you’re doing it but the people being impacted don’t even know that you’re doing it.”

Thank you for reading. I’m open for tips, suggestions and feedback on Instagram @katemorrisseyjournalist and on Bluesky @bgirledukate.

In Other News

8 years old: ICE officers detained an 8-year-old boy by himself when he came with a family member for his check-in appointment, Alexander Nguyen reported for KPBS. San Diegans rallied the following week with calls to bring him home.

A gun and a Taser: An ICE officer pointed a gun and Taser at an 18-year-old student after crashing into her father’s car to arrest him, I reported for Daylight San Diego.

County-funded attorneys: Alexandra Mendoza reported for The San Diego Union-Tribune that clients of the county-funded immigration legal defense program are spending longer time in custody and are more often transferred from other states.

SDPD and ICE: I reported for Daylight San Diego that Councilmember Sean Elo-Rivera is calling on the San Diego Police Department to be more transparent about its calls involving ICE.

Kate Morrissey has been a journalist covering immigration issues at the San Diego-Tijuana border since 2016. She worked at The San Diego Union-Tribune...

Leave a comment

We expect all commenters to be constructive and civil. We reserve the right to delete comments without explanation. You are welcome to flag comments to us. You are welcome to submit an opinion piece for our editors to review.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.