Opinion

D.A. Candidate: Why the D.A.’s Office Would Be Sidelined in a Filner Probe

D.A. Candidate: Why the D.A.’s Office Would Be Sidelined in a Filner Probe

Photo by Sam Hodgson

Bonnie Dumanis

Any potential criminal investigation into sexual harassment allegations against Mayor Bob Filner, announced by the San Diego Sheriff’s Department on July 19, would be missing a key player because of District Attorney Bonnie Dumanis’ political activities.

Fix San Diego Opinion Logo In the last paragraph of a July 19 U-T San Diego article:

“The District Attorney’s Office also put out a news release about the same time as the Sheriff’s Department saying it would not be part of a sexual harassment investigation of Filner. District Attorney Bonnie Dumanis ran unsuccessfully for mayor last year, coming in last in a four-candidate primary.”

Not stated in the article is the fact that Dumanis was forced to recuse herself from what could be one of the most high-profile criminal investigations in many years, transferring prosecutorial authority to the state attorney general’s office, because of her high-profile political activity related to last year’s mayoral race.

Dumanis’ political campaign for mayor against Filner while simultaneously serving as the District Attorney, and later her endorsement of mayoral candidate Carl DeMaio, destroyed the necessary impartiality required of a prosecutor to investigate.

If ever there were proof of how a “political” district attorney can compromise an investigation – here it is.

The more than 300 deputy district attorneys in her office, among the best and brightest criminal trial lawyers in the county, cannot do their job because their boss spent 17 months running for mayor, politicking and making deals with political insiders. She did not take an unpaid leave of absence, did not return any of her $240,000-a-year government salary while running, and now, a year later, her “activities” still negatively impact the office that should be involved, shoulder-to-shoulder, with the sheriff during this very important investigation.

But because Dumanis put her personal political ambitions before everything else – just 70 days after she was sworn into office for her third term as district attorney – her office of experienced criminal prosecutors is precluded from doing its job.

Dumanis previously recognized the impropriety of politicizing her office when, in 2007, she rolled out her Public Integrity Unit. At that time, she promised she would not endorse or accept endorsements from political office holders so as not to compromise the work of that unit. Since then, in violation of her own promise, she has endorsed numerous candidates for local office, from the county treasurer to mayors and even judges. And she has accepted political endorsements from a slew of politicians in the upcoming district attorney’s race.

Now we see the consequences: her office is precluded from investigating a very important case because of her political activities.

That’s why I am committed to eliminating politics from the district attorney’s office and why, as district attorney, I will never endorse politicians. It’s time to restore public safety without politics.

(Update: Read District Attorney Bonnie Dumanis’ response.)

Brewer’s commentary has been edited for clarity. See anything in there we should fact check? Tell us here. Want to respond? Submit a commentary.

Voice of San Diego is a nonprofit that depends on you, our readers. Please donate to keep the service strong. Click here to find out more about our supporters and how we operate independently.


Robert Brewer

Robert Brewer

Robert Brewer is an attorney in private practice and a candidate for San Diego County District Attorney.

  • 0 Posts
  • 21
    Followers

Show comments
Before you comment, read these simple guidelines on what is not allowed.

6 comments
Jim Jones
Jim Jones

So this is a campaign ad? Bob, if elected will you make public the complete file on the Gentiel investigation? BTW, If I run for mayor I promise not to run for DA when I am in office, or to lick anyones face unless clearly invited to do so! I will screw over both the unions and the hotels when ever I can, put a suggestion box along side every doggie bag dispenser and change the police uniform to bright pink and the cars to smart cars!

Jim Jones
Jim Jones subscriber

So this is a campaign ad? Bob, if elected will you make public the complete file on the Gentiel investigation? BTW, If I run for mayor I promise not to run for DA when I am in office, or to lick anyones face unless clearly invited to do so! I will screw over both the unions and the hotels when ever I can, put a suggestion box along side every doggie bag dispenser and change the police uniform to bright pink and the cars to smart cars!

dave stutz
dave stutz

This article exposes the way Dumanis has destroyed what was once one of the best prosecutors offices in the country. Her political ego has sent the message to her 300 attorneys that she doesn't like being DA and wants a higher political office. Moral in the office is the lowest it has been in the last 40 years. She must go so we can get an impartical, objective DA with no higher political ambitions.

dave stutz
dave stutz subscribermember

This article exposes the way Dumanis has destroyed what was once one of the best prosecutors offices in the country. Her political ego has sent the message to her 300 attorneys that she doesn't like being DA and wants a higher political office. Moral in the office is the lowest it has been in the last 40 years. She must go so we can get an impartical, objective DA with no higher political ambitions.

David Crossley
David Crossley

I honestly don't remember--didn't she run unopposed in her last election cycle?

David Crossley
David Crossley subscriber

I honestly don't remember--didn't she run unopposed in her last election cycle?