Living With ‘Food Insecurity’ in an Era of Abundance

Living With ‘Food Insecurity’ in an Era of Abundance

Photo by Bianca Bruno

Willie Guyton, a retired military worker, receives groceries from a Bridge of Hope volunteer. He has been coming to the food pantry for the past two years and said his fixed income makes it difficult to buy healthy food and pay bills.

Every Tuesday evening 19-year-old Alex walks a few blocks from his home in central Santa Ana to the La Semilla Calvary Chapel to pick up a box of produce for his family.

He picks from over a hundred boxes overflowing with fruits and vegetables — from eggplant to squash to bananas — assembled on banquet tables by church volunteers.

All of the produce is usable, but much of it is overripe and wouldn’t pass muster at a supermarket. Yet, in a given week it might be the only fresh food that Alex, whose father is unemployed, has access to.

“I love the fresh produce,” said the Santa Ana College student who didn’t want his full name used. “It gives me energy for school. I usually use it to make juice or smoothies.”

Alex is not in a state of starvation. But like the more than 90 other Santa Ana families La Semilla serves every week, he is affected by “food insecurity,” which is a lack of consistent access to nutritious food.

It is an issue that public health experts are increasingly putting front and center as low-income neighborhoods are besieged by an obesity epidemic that has led to spiraling rates of heart disease, diabetes and other nutrition-related ailments.

There are few places where the problem is more acute than in the urban centers of Southern California. A study released earlier this year showed that on a county-by-county basis California has the fourth-highest rate of food insecurity among children nationwide.

In San Diego, a quarter of City Heights residents are affected by food insecurity, and countywide close to 160,000 children are lacking regular access to nutritious food. City Heights’ rates are similar to those in Santa Ana, an Orange County community that is also largely low-income and Latino.

The Problem Is Access, Not Ignorance

As public health experts both locally and nationally work to improve these conditions, they have come to realize that personal choices about the nutritional quality of the food a family consumes has a lot more to do with access than it does with ignorance.

Jennifer Gilmore, executive director of Feeding America San Diego said the realization forced her to change the internal culture of her organization, starting with herself.

“I went in with some assumptions,” she said. “I thought families were choosing not to eat healthy food. I had to educate myself as families would come up to me requesting that we provide healthier options.”

It goes without saying, Gilmore said, that increasing access to healthy food, increases consumption of healthy food. This is why Feeding America increasingly turns down donors who bring them processed food. She said Feeding America doesn’t distribute any candy, soda or chips. Currently half of all its food is fruits and vegetables, and 75 percent of the food it provides is considered highly nutritious.

This change in approach comes as the Great Recession and its aftermath has caused a widening in the pool of families needing food pantries to include those who were formally middle class and many who are currently employed, said Janet Shellenberger, volunteer at the First Lutheran food pantry in Fullerton.

“They may be working, but they don’t have 40-hour-a-week jobs,” she said. “Most of our clients work in service industry jobs that can’t afford to give them benefits. So they have to work two or three jobs just to get the 40 hours they need.”

This past October, Shellenberger said First Lutheran served over 300 clients during food pantry hours on what should have been a routine Wednesday. It was toward the end of the month, when most low-income people are strapped for cash.

“We see more people at the end of the month,” Shellenberger said. “There’s just too much month for their money.”

Finding Fresh Produce in a Food Desert

Photo by Bianca Bruno

Photo by Bianca Bruno

Alejandra Pena and her family are volunteers at Bridge of Hope's weekly food pantry. The family is food insecure and relied heavily upon food assistance from the pantry when their food stamps were taken away this year.

Public health experts call places like City Heights and many neighborhoods in Santa Ana, where fresh food options are scarce, “food deserts.”

Since 2008, Bridge of Hope works to change this reality in City Heights by hosting a weekly food pantry that serves between 250 and 280 community members.

Volunteer Alejandra Pena has been working at the food pantry for five years — and like the City Heights residents she serves, she and her family are food insecure. This summer the family’s food budget was cut dramatically when the federal government  determined that they earned too much money to be eligible for food assistance and took away their $400-per-month food stamp allocation.

She said the food she received from Bridge of Hope was sometimes all her family of six would have for a week.

“The kids, they don’t understand when you try to tell them there’s nothing else to eat,” she said. “We struggled a lot this year.”

Emergency food assistance used to help families get by for a day or a week, experts say it’s now used as a long-term supplement to get by. Gilmore said that as food assistance programs become the primary source of food for some low-income families, they must take a look at the quality of food they’re providing.

“To say we’re emergency food is less and less true,” she said. “There isn’t a neutral food — you’re either helping or harming.”

To prevent the fresh food from going, as Gilmore puts it, “from farm, to family, to trash,” Feeding America provides cooking classes and recipe cards to clients. The organization also engages in “client choice,” or allowing families to pick the food they want, rather than giving clients a bag of pre-selected items.

Such demands have put the strain on small food pantries, where having enough to go around is always a concern. And with public health experts sounding the alarm about the quality of food being distributed, the need goes far beyond what a traditional canned food drive can provide.

This is where the Orange County Food Access Coalition comes in. The coalition has a program called The Harvest Club, where residential gardeners can donate excess produce from their backyards to emergency food providers.

Executive Director Gillian Poe said that 60 percent of Orange County residents have fruit trees, where a surplus can go a long way. They’re even hosting a healthier food drive with Starbucks to educate donors on what to give.

“Rather than clear out their pantry of food they don’t want, they should think about what they would want or need to eat if they were in a position requiring food assistance,” Poe said. “It’s not an acceptable response to people in need to think, ‘As long as we bring a bag of food we did our part.’”

Shellenberger said First Lutheran gets 41,000 pounds of fresh produce for $250 a week as a part of the Second Harvest Farm to Family program. Albert Quintanilla, director of community outreach for La Semilla, said their monthly food bill at Second Harvest is between $400 and $500.

Both pantries try to provide as much fresh fruits and vegetables to their clients as possible.

Yet despite all of these efforts, Poe says there’s a cultural disconnect about hunger in America.

“People don’t understand how you can be overweight and hungry,” she said. “Painting the public health picture for people is important because when our neighbors aren’t well, we’re a much weaker community.”

Voice of San Diego is a nonprofit that depends on you, our readers. Please donate to keep the service strong. Click here to find out more about our supporters and how we operate independently.


Bianca Bruno

Bianca Bruno

Bianca Bruno is an intern for Speak City Heights, a media project of Voice of San Diego, KPBS, Media Arts Center and The AjA Project. You can reach her at bbruno@kpbs.org.

  • 5 Posts
  • 4
    Followers

Show comments
Before you comment, read these simple guidelines on what is not allowed.

11 comments
Joe Jones
Joe Jones

"Food insecurity" is a euphemism for "food stupidity." I'm trying to wrap my head around that the idea that the poor Pena family, six starving souls who earn too much money to qualify for fed freebies and includes a member who's worked at the Food Pantry for five years, is somehow on the verge of extinction due to lack of nutrition education. I applaud the fact that these organizations are attempting to distribute quality food. I'm just amazed by the naivete served for dessert.

Joe Jones
Joe Jones subscriber

"Food insecurity" is a euphemism for "food stupidity." I'm trying to wrap my head around that the idea that the poor Pena family, six starving souls who earn too much money to qualify for fed freebies and includes a member who's worked at the Food Pantry for five years, is somehow on the verge of extinction due to lack of nutrition education. I applaud the fact that these organizations are attempting to distribute quality food. I'm just amazed by the naivete served for dessert.

JLDodd
JLDodd

Wow! You have to suspend disbelief to read this "food insecurity" stuff. Traveling in the third world will show you real food insecurity…jim dodd

Matt Finish
Matt Finish

"was sometimes all her family of six would have for a week"

If someone is poor, and resources are scarce, why do they expand the number of consumers of said scarce resources by reproducing irresponsibly?

Emotionally charged catch phrases like "food insecurity" and "food deserts" are just the latest jargon used to justify expanding a multi-trillion dollar welfare state. Completely absent from the discussion is any mention of personal responsibility. That absence is not an accident.

Matt Finish
Matt Finish subscriber

"was sometimes all her family of six would have for a week"

If someone is poor, and resources are scarce, why do they expand the number of consumers of said scarce resources by reproducing irresponsibly?

Emotionally charged catch phrases like "food insecurity" and "food deserts" are just the latest jargon used to justify expanding a multi-trillion dollar welfare state. Completely absent from the discussion is any mention of personal responsibility. That absence is not an accident.

Glenn Younger
Glenn Younger

The Harvest Club & 2nd Harvest in Orange County and Senior Gleaners in Sacramento show that it is not a food production problem (each county produces far more than they can eat) it is a harvesting and distribution problem.

Is there an organization that is actively doing this in San Diego County?
The Harvest Club Orange Countyhttp://www.theharvestclub.org/The Harvest Club of Orange County helps people with an abundance of fresh fruits and vegetables they cannot or would not harvest themselves and donate the food to the underserved with our volunteer harvesting teams.Senior Gleaners INC. | Serving the hungry since 1976http://seniorgleaners.org/POWERED BY VOLUNTEERS Volunteers are the heartbeat of Senior Gleaners. Volunteering is a great way to meet people of like-mind and for individuals, families, and groups to help those less fortunate in our community.

Glenn Younger
Glenn Younger subscribermember

The Harvest Club & 2nd Harvest in Orange County and Senior Gleaners in Sacramento show that it is not a food production problem (each county produces far more than they can eat) it is a harvesting and distribution problem.

Is there an organization that is actively doing this in San Diego County?
The Harvest Club Orange Countyhttp://www.theharvestclub.org/The Harvest Club of Orange County helps people with an abundance of fresh fruits and vegetables they cannot or would not harvest themselves and donate the food to the underserved with our volunteer harvesting teams.Senior Gleaners INC. | Serving the hungry since 1976http://seniorgleaners.org/POWERED BY VOLUNTEERS Volunteers are the heartbeat of Senior Gleaners. Volunteering is a great way to meet people of like-mind and for individuals, families, and groups to help those less fortunate in our community.

Mark Giffin
Mark Giffin

" it is a harvesting and distribution problem".
Its a fair statement
Citrus is a good example. There is an abundance in San Diego county
Its labor intensive to harvest, requires transport and needs to be taken....somewhere.

Mark Giffin
Mark Giffin subscribermember

" it is a harvesting and distribution problem".
Its a fair statement
Citrus is a good example. There is an abundance in San Diego county
Its labor intensive to harvest, requires transport and needs to be taken....somewhere.