A Flock camera in Fall River, Massachusetts on Tuesday, Oct. 6, 2026. (Anastasia E. Lennon / The New Bedford Light via AP)

Monday’s San Diego City Council meeting featured an incredible cast of public commenters. Luke Skywalker and Leia were there. So was Walter Sobchak, Jeff Goodman’s paranoiac libertarian character from “The Big Lebowski.” A resident of one of television’s most famous streets dropped in, as well.  

“Me ask city council, does tracking innocent people violate civil rights?” said a man dressed in a bright blue Cookie Monster costume. “If those cameras don’t come down, Cookie Monster gonna eat them all – num, num, num, num, num, num, num!” 

Perhaps fearing Cookie Monster’s wrath, San Diego’s City Council voted unanimously on Monday to rescind the city’s use policy for its sprawling network of 500 automated license plate readers. The vote means that within 24 hours, the city’s cameras will go dark and all data will be deleted, a San Diego Police Department spokesperson said during the meeting.

The cameras operate using license plate detection software from the controversial tech firm Flock. 

A related motion to suspend the use of the city’s smart streetlights, which record video used by SDPD, also passed 5-2. 

The decision makes San Diego the largest city in America to shut off its ALPR network.  

“This is a win for community,” Councilmember Sean Elo-Rivera, who has led the charge against Flock, wrote in a social media post. “San Diegans deserve to feel safe, but most importantly, they need to trust that government hears them and will find alternative ways to protect their safety that doesn’t require surveillance.” 

The physical cameras will remain, however, at least for now. Mayor Todd Gloria must first cancel the city’s contract with Ubicquia, the vendor that provided the cameras, before they can be removed. 

By Monday, the City Council’s decision seemed inevitable. But the political winds had shifted quickly. As recently as June, an effort to ditch ALPR’s by Councilmembers Henry Foster, Vivian Moreno, Kent Lee and Elo-Rivera failed.  

Over the past year, national backlash against surveillance firm Flock, and automated license plate readers more broadly, grew. Fears about its use by immigration authorities and potential abuse by law enforcement fueled the opposition.  

Locally, a high-profile misidentification that left an innocent man behind bars for a month acted as confirmation of skeptics’ fears. The technology became so toxic that misleading mailers during the recent election claimed a staunchly anti-Flock candidate was actually pro-Flock.  

Last month, the Council defections began.  

They started with Councilmember Stephen Whitburn, who in mid-October announced he would no longer support the city’s use of the technology. That gave the council its first anti-ALPR majority.

Next came Councilmember Raul Campillo, long a champion of ALPR’s. Last week, Campillo cited a case reported by Voice of San Diego that SDPD had surveilled a domestic violence victim and fellow officers using the system. 

“Learning that the Police Department used ALPRs inappropriately to surveil one of their own and a member of the public calls the entire program into question,” Campillo wrote in a statement. 

Over the weekend, Councilmember (and U.S. Rep.-elect) Marni von Wilpert hopped on the anti-Flock train. Von Wilpert called for a pause in the technology’s use until “there is a stronger oversight policy that strengthens the transparency we need to deliver true public safety.” 

Von Wilpert missed the vote due to “schedule changes in mandatory training requirements for my incoming federal office.” 

By Monday night, even Council President Joe LaCava voted against the city’s use of ALPR’s. LaCava had long supported the city’s use of the technology, largely because of its utility as a crime-fighting tool and the safeguards the city had put in place. Ultimately, those weren’t enough, he concluded.  

“Perhaps we indeed have the most secure operation anywhere in the country, and best security of the data. But frankly, the best in the nation is not always good enough,” LaCava said. “I see no path in preserving a law enforcement tool that wants to meet the needs of San Diegans and yet cannot address very real and very concerning issues.”   

Jakob McWhinney is Voice of San Diego's Enterprise Reporter.

Leave a comment

We expect all commenters to be constructive and civil. We reserve the right to delete comments without explanation. You are welcome to flag comments to us. You are welcome to submit an opinion piece for our editors to review.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.