Chula Vista City Council meeting at the Chula Vista Council Chambers on Tuesday, Nov. 4, 2025. /Vito Di Stefano for Voice of San Diego

Chula Vista City Councilmember Jose Preciado this week begged his colleagues to do him, and the rest of the city, a favor. 

In short: Lay down your weapons and get along. 

“I must tell you, our last meeting was uncomfortable for me because language and accusations were used,” Preciado said at Tuesday’s City Council meeting, referring to a Council discussion last week about city proclamations that devolved into a bitter debate and personal attacks. 

“We need to figure out how to handle these things,” Preciado said. “Not all of us to become best friends, but agree or disagree in an agreeable manner.” 

Last year, it was the National City Council generating headlines for personal feuds and slash-and-burn battles on the dais. 

This year, Chula Vista leaders seem to be vying to become, at least in some residents’ view, South County’s most childish elected officials. 

“Some of the behavior I see from the City Council reminds me of a school playground,” said recent City Council candidate Angelica Martinez at last week’s Council meeting. “The difference is, you are all elected officials, not children. And taxpayers are paying for this show.” 

The debates animating councilmembers’ disputes are arcane, personal and exhausting to detail. Readers keen to witness what Martinez called “the Chula Vista City Council novelas” can stream recent meetings on the city’s website. 

Recent debates have featured wild public comments, procedural maneuvering and words such as “drunken Baja beach festival,” “blatant lies” and “maliciously hijacking.” 

Martinez, who mounted an unsuccessful attempt this year to unseat Preciado from the Council, summed up residents’ feelings about it all. 

“When are you going to stop the political drama and wasting taxpayers’ time and money and start focusing on the issues residents actually care about?” she said to councilmembers last week. “Crime, homelessness, public safety, deteriorating infrastructure, rising costs, city budgets and small businesses struggling to survive…Instead, we are here watching grown adults fight over authority and ceremonial proclamations like children arguing over who gets to be in charge of the playground.” 

Perhaps in a signal of how widespread public feeling about the disunion has become, Preciado on Tuesday struck a tone similar to that of his former campaign opponent. 

“I don’t want to continue at this pace,” he said. “We need to resolve our differences.” 

Preciado suggested bringing in a mediator or facilitator to “help us better communicate dissatisfaction.” 

To that end, Preciado urged his colleagues to address one major source of public controversy: Ongoing fallout from an unsuccessful proposal earlier this year to place a government overhaul voter initiative on the November ballot. 

That proposal, authored and backed by a prominent local labor union, generated intense public opposition and resulted in accusations of backroom deals and undue special interest influence. 

Preciado said he feared a repeat of the black eye the Council suffered following the resignation two years ago of Councilmember Andrea Cardenas. Along with her brother, Democratic political consultant Jesus Cardenas, Andrea Cardenas pleaded guilty to defrauding taxpayers and stepped down from the Council. 

Preciado urged his colleagues to put to rest controversy over the government overhaul ballot measure by making public all written Council communications regarding the issue. 

“I don’t want our city to continue like we did two to three years ago,” he said. “If you want to see our engagement [on the ballot measure,] have at it.” 

The Council, in a rare moment of harmony, unanimously agreed and voted to consider Preciado’s records release proposal at their Dec. 15 meeting. 

“We have too much at stake,” Preciado said, citing a list of issues strikingly similar to the list Martinez cited last week. “We need to put our best step forward.” 

Teachers Union Leader Gets Administrative Job Despite Pushback 

The Chula Vista Elementary School District Board of Trustees late Wednesday voted 3-2 to give teachers union president Rosi Martinez a new job as District Director of Community Schools, placing her among the top ranks of district administrators. 

Trustees Jessica Tolston, Francisco Tamayo and Lucy Ugarte voted in favor. Trustees Delia Dominguez Cervantes and Keren Ramirez Dominguez were opposed. 

The vote by the board’s union-backed Democratic majority came despite vocal pushback from teachers at the meeting and, in an earlier interview with Voice of San Diego, from the district’s former community schools director. 

Teachers and the former director objected that hiring Martinez for the job, which commands a salary of up to $176,781, constituted a conflict of interest and showed signs of political favoritism. 

In an earlier statement to Voice, Martinez rejected those allegations and said her decades of experience as an educator and backer of the district’s community schools program eminently qualified her for the job. 

Teachers at Wednesday’s board meeting pointed out that at the time Martinez was interviewing for the community schools job, the teachers union was negotiating a new employment contract with the district. 

Teachers questioned Martinez’s ability to represent them while also seeking a job from district leaders. Other speakers objected to the job’s high salary at a time of budget constraints and pointed out that the teachers union had politically supported all three board members who voted for the new appointment. 

“On a deep personal level, this transition feels like a personal betrayal to the rank and file,” said sixth grade teacher Monica Tevelein. 

Board members voted on the appointment behind closed doors at the very end of Wednesday’s seven-hour meeting. Trustee Dominguez reported the appointment without comment. 

Also at the Chula Vista board meeting: Teachers and community members protested recent district moves signaling possible plans to change or cut Chula Vista Elementary’s vaunted arts programs. You can read excellent coverage of this issue by inewsource’s Andrea Figueroa Briseño here and here. 

In Other News 

  • The National City Council on Tuesday once again postponed votes on a new contract for city towing services and a proposal to raise the city’s business license tax. In both instances, councilmembers sought more information from city staff and said the matters were better addressed by the Council after new members are sworn in later this year. You can read my previous coverage of the two issues here and here. 
  • Chula Vista City Councilmembers on Tuesday directed city housing officials to explore stiffening the city’s homeless encampment ban and implementing additional rental assistance measures as the city works to finalize a new strategic plan for homeless services. Councilmembers echoed a recent trend of South County elected officials voicing frustration with current homelessness strategies and questioning the effectiveness of so-called Housing First policies. “We can build all the housing in the world, but if people won’t accept services, we can’t solve the problem,” said Councilmember Jose Preciado. 
  • The Port of San Diego this week announced plans to repair an eroded section of embankment alongside the Bayshore Bikeway in Imperial Beach. 
  • County supervisors Paloma Aguirre and Joel Anderson on Tuesday announced a bipartisan measure to invest $600,000 in a countywide expansion of the Dolly Parton’s Imagination Library program, which provides books to young children. 

Jim Hinch is Voice of San Diego's South county reporter.

Leave a comment

We expect all commenters to be constructive and civil. We reserve the right to delete comments without explanation. You are welcome to flag comments to us. You are welcome to submit an opinion piece for our editors to review.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.